John Toner, Yuhai Tu, et al.
Annals of Physics
The criticism by Siggia (in the preceding Comment) of recent work developing a dynamical theory of the liquid-glass transitin is shwn to be based on unphysical and mathematically unjustified mappings onto systems unrelated to those proposed to have a glass transition. His subsequent arguments misrepresent the structure of the transition that has been proposed. © 1985 The American Physical Society.
John Toner, Yuhai Tu, et al.
Annals of Physics
Dov Levine, T.C. Lubensky, et al.
Physical Review Letters
Gene F. Mazenko, Sriram Ramaswamy, et al.
Physical Review A
Shankar P. Das, Gene F. Mazenko, et al.
Physical Review Letters